First off, a huge shoutout to Austin--I believe he's the manager or owner. The level of customer service he provided to my boyfriend and me was truly exceptional. We had just finished a 10 hour drive on our road trip up north and shared how excited we were to finally dine here. From the moment we arrived, Austin made us feel so welcome. He personally seated us, was incredibly attentive, and even surprised us with a complimentary appetizer, such a thoughtful touch. Thank you, Austin!

The clam chowder was the main reason we came, and it absolutely lived up to the hype SO delicious. The ambiance, the views, and the overall atmosphere made the entire experience even better.

As we were leaving, we stopped to thank Austin and let him know how much we enjoyed everything. While we were outside purchasing some clam chowder to take home for our family, he somehow noticed us and generously covered our purchase. Completely unexpected and so appreciated.

Austin, you truly know how to run a business and create an unforgettable customer experience. We can't wait to come back and we've already recommended this place to family members. Thank you again!

Amazing experience! Came here for an anniversary dinner. Staff was so friendly and helpful. Helped us pick a bottle of local wine and walked through the menu. Landed on the seafood pasta and risotto plates. Food was great!
Stop reading this review and set a reservation!

The ambiance and ocean view were truly stunning, coupled with delicious fresh food, while the stall staff, particularly Sal the waiter, were incredibly friendly and professional. I highly recommend visiting the Old Fisherman Grotta, an excellent location for spending family time.

Sal was an excellent server and was very helpful in menu recommendations
The food was delicious. Our group had the captain's plate, surf and turf, crab tower, coconut shrimp, calamari, and macadamia nut crusted halibut. Relaxing dining experience.

Love the locals menu option. 3 course meal for a great price. Can't go wrong when you can't decide where to eat.

Went back after a great first visit and it held up. Had a weekend reservation and got seated right away at a really nice table with a good view. Service was smooth and very attentive. They brought out a complimentary appetizer, which was a nice touch (and definitely appreciated with hungry kids at the table).

We ordered the halibut special, the ultimate seafood pasta, and an alfredo. Portions were generous across the board, and the halibut was especially well done, cooked just right. Overall, a solid experience again.

The food was yummy . This was our first time here. We were seated right away on the 2nd floor; the view on the water was nice. The service was great, I didn't have to call anyone to refill my (ice tea) drink.
The calamari was so yummy; not chewy. The clam chowder bowel was WoW!! The toasted garlic top on the bowel was amazing!!! The husband loved the seafood pasta!!! The cherry on top was getting a long stem rose courtesy of the restaurant!!! Great Customer Service!!! Thank you for an amazing dinner!!!

I am a resident in Monterey and I love going to fisherman's Grotto. I love to see Mr. Shake and his family. I met Chris Shake's son Austin today. Very nice young man. Me and my family had a great experience as always.

Best meal out we've had in a long time!! Truly in a class above the rest (like old time dining use to be.) Food, wine list, service, and ambience was first class. Quality and variety truly exceptional, portions large, prices relatively low, extremely high value. We loved everything including our Crab cocktail starter, famous clam chowder and house salad. Tara was our waitress. A true gem. Can't recommend this restaurant enough!